Breathing exercises for panic attacks: what the trials found
Slow, regular breathing, practised when you are calm, is what the panic disorder trials taught. Why big deep breaths and the paper bag are not it.
- Written by
- Pauso Team
- Published
- Reading time
- 6 minutes

The breathing exercise for a panic attack is slow and regular: breathe in through your nose for about 4 seconds and out for about 6, without forcing big breaths, for a few minutes. The trials of breathing training for panic disorder taught people to breathe slowly and shallowly, and to practise every day while calm, so the pattern was familiar before the next attack.
Breathing training has helped people with panic disorder in trials, but the trials suggest the exact pattern matters less than people think, and none of them tested a technique in the middle of an attack. The NHS names talking therapy and medicine as the main treatments for panic disorder, and recommends breathing exercises alongside them.
What to do during a panic attack
- Stay where you are if you can. NHS inform's advice is to stay in the situation, because it "shows you that you don't have to escape for the panic to stop".
- Slow your breathing down, not up. Breathe in gently through your nose for about 4 seconds and let the breath out for about 6. Keep the breaths small. Gulping air can add to the dizziness.
- Follow a count or a pacer rather than judging each breath. The pacer below runs 4 in and 6 out.
- Tell yourself what is happening. The NHS says most panic attacks last 5 to 20 minutes and are not dangerous. Reminding yourself that the attack will pass is part of its advice.
- Keep going for a few minutes, even when the first minute does not seem to work.
Extended exhale
In 4 sOut 6 s
If breathing at a set count makes you more anxious, NHS inform's self-help guide offers a simpler version: breathe slowly, gently, and out for longer than in. It also notes that body-focused advice does not suit everyone, and that turning your attention to what is around you is an alternative.
If you have chest pain and have never had a panic attack before, or you are not sure it is one, get medical help first.
What the panic disorder trials found
The best evidence comes from capnometry-assisted respiratory training, a four-week course in which people with panic disorder practised breathing while a monitor showed the carbon dioxide in their breath. Many people with panic disorder breathe too much at rest, which lowers carbon dioxide and can bring on dizziness and tingling. The training aimed to raise it.
| Study | Who | What they practised | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meuret et al., Journal of Psychiatric Research, 2008 | 37 people with panic disorder, randomised to training or a wait list | 17 minutes twice a day for 4 weeks, following tones that slowed each week from 13 to 6 breaths a minute | Panic severity fell far more than on the wait list (d = 2.21). 68% were panic-free a year later, though that follow-up had no comparison group. |
| Meuret et al., Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 2010 | 41 people with panic disorder and agoraphobia | The same breathing course, or cognitive training instead | Panic symptoms fell about equally in both groups. Only the breathing group's carbon dioxide levels returned to normal. |
| Kim, Wollburg and Roth, Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 2012 | 74 people with panic disorder | Training to raise carbon dioxide, training to lower it, or a wait list | Both opposite trainings reduced panic severity, with large effects a month later (1.34 and 1.53), held at six months. |
The Kim trial is the most useful one for choosing a pattern. Two breathing courses with opposite goals worked about as well as each other. The authors concluded the benefit came from what the courses shared, which they suggest may be changed beliefs and expectations, facing the bodily sensations of panic, and "attention to regular and slow breathing".
The evidence has clear limits. These were small trials, without a placebo group. A larger uncontrolled trial of the same method in 69 people reported that 54% were in remission after treatment, but it was funded by the company that makes the device (Tolin et al., Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback, 2017). In a trial of 77 people that removed breathing retraining from cognitive behavioural therapy, the therapy worked about as well without it (Schmidt et al., Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 2000). A 2023 review found 16 studies of breathwork alone in people with diagnosed anxiety disorders, mostly small and too varied to pool (Banushi et al., Brain Sciences, 2023).
Why big deep breaths can make it worse
"Take a deep breath" is the advice most people hear, and during panic it can backfire. Breathing too deeply or too fast is hyperventilation, and a meta-analysis of breathing at rest found that people with panic disorder already breathe more air per minute and have lower carbon dioxide than people without it (Grassi et al., Journal of Affective Disorders, 2013). The trials above taught slow, shallow, regular breaths. The NHS says to breathe slowly and deeply but "without forcing it". The NHS, NHS inform and the trials above all say slow.
Should you breathe into a paper bag?
No. The paper bag is meant to restore carbon dioxide, but it also lowers oxygen. In 20 healthy volunteers who hyperventilated and then breathed into a paper bag, oxygen fell by an average of 26.6 mm Hg within three minutes, and by 42 mm Hg in one person, while many never got their carbon dioxide back to normal (Callaham, Annals of Emergency Medicine, 1989). The same paper reports three deaths in which the bag was given to people whose breathlessness came from low oxygen or a heart problem, not panic. In a separate experiment, symptoms eased just as fast when people only believed they were rebreathing from the bag (van den Hout et al., Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 1988). Slowing your breathing carries no such risk.
Does 4-7-8 or box breathing stop a panic attack?
We found no trial of 4-7-8 breathing, or of box breathing, in panic attacks or panic disorder. Both include breath holds. If you are prone to panic or to feeling short of air, drop the holds. Box breathing for anxiety covers what its trials found in people without panic disorder. For an attack, a pattern with no holds is the safer choice, such as the 4 in, 6 out extended exhale above.
Practise when you are calm
Every trial above used daily practice over weeks, not a technique learned in the moment. NHS inform's guide says to practise "even when you're feeling calm, so you can get used to them and use them automatically when you start to panic". Five minutes a day is enough to make the count familiar. In the general population the effect is small: across 20 randomised trials, mostly in people without a diagnosis, they were linked to lower anxiety than control conditions (Fincham et al., Scientific Reports, 2023).
How common are panic attacks?
More than one in four adults has had at least one. In a US national survey of 9,282 adults, 28.3% reported a panic attack at some point in their life, and 4.7% had had panic disorder, which means repeated, unexpected attacks and a month or more of worrying about the next one (Kessler et al., Archives of General Psychiatry, 2006). A single panic attack is not a disorder. If they keep coming back, talk to a doctor. The NHS names talking therapy, such as cognitive behavioural therapy, and medicine as the main treatments.
Panic at work
A panic attack at your desk or in a meeting calls for the same steps: stay put if you can, slow the breath, and let it pass. Anxiety at work covers three desk exercises and when to use each. A breathing habit is easier to keep with other people, and a short session with your team each week is one way to keep the practice going on calm days.



