Box breathing vs 4-7-8
Box breathing (in 4, hold 4, out 4, hold 4) keeps every count equal, so it is easy to do anywhere, including just before you speak. 4-7-8 (in 4, hold 7, out 8) has a long hold and a breath out twice the breath in, which makes it the more relaxing of the two and better kept for winding down. Neither has strong direct evidence: box breathing has one month-long trial from 2023, and 4-7-8 one small study of 43 young adults with no comparison group.
By the Pauso Team. Published .
Side by side
| Box breathing | 4-7-8 breathing | |
|---|---|---|
| Pattern | In 4 s, Hold 4 s, Out 4 s, Hold 4 s | In 4 s, Hold 7 s, Out 8 s |
| One round | 16 s | 19 s |
| Breaths a minute | 3.8 | 3.2 |
| Holds | Two, 4 s each | One, 7 s |
| Breath out | Equal to the breath in | Twice the breath in |
| Good for | Steadying yourself before work that needs attention, or just before a call. Silent, so it works with a camera on. | Winding down at the end of the day. |
| Skip it | When breath holds feel uncomfortable, or if you are prone to panic. Breathe in for 4 and out for 4 instead. | Just before you have to speak, or when the 7-second hold makes you lightheaded. Shorten the hold, or stop. |
| Shortest useful sitting | 4 rounds, about a minute | 4 rounds, about a minute |
Try both
Four rounds of each takes about a minute. Notice how you feel after each one.
Box breathing
Box breathing
In 4 sHold 4 sOut 4 sHold 4 s
Open box breathing in the timer to change the seconds or go full screen.
4-7-8 breathing
4-7-8 breathing
In 4 sHold 7 sOut 8 s
Open 4-7-8 breathing in the timer to change the seconds or go full screen.
Which one to use when
- Before a meeting, a call or anything where you need to talk, use box breathing. 4-7-8 is the more relaxing of the two, and its long hold makes some people lightheaded.
- At the end of the day, to wind down, use 4-7-8.
- If breath holds feel uncomfortable, use neither as written. Breathe in for 4 and out for 4, or in for 4 and out for 6, with no holds.
- As a first practice with a team, use box breathing. Most people know the name, so nobody needs it explained.
Breathing out for longer with no holds at all is extended exhale breathing.
What the research found
No study has compared the two directly. Each has been tested on its own, in small studies.
Box breathing
In a month-long trial, five minutes of box breathing lowered anxiety from before to after each daily session.
Balban et al., Cell Reports Medicine, 2023 (opens the paper in a new tab). A change within the box breathing group. It lifted mood more than meditation did, but not by a significant margin; cyclic sighing did better.
A review of 15 studies linked breathing under ten breaths a minute with more relaxation and comfort and less anxiety.
Zaccaro et al., Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 2018 (opens the paper in a new tab). Box breathing runs at under four breaths a minute, inside that range. The studies were in healthy adults, and breath holds were not studied on their own.
4-7-8 breathing
In 43 young adults, a few minutes of 4-7-8 breathing lowered heart rate and systolic blood pressure straight afterwards.
Vierra et al., Physiological Reports, 2022 (opens the paper in a new tab). Three sets of six rounds, measured before and after, with no comparison breathing group. It is the only direct study of note.
In a study of 30 adults, a long breath out with a shorter breath in felt more relaxing than the reverse, at slow and normal rates.
Van Diest et al., Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback, 2014 (opens the paper in a new tab). A small lab study of the ratio, not of 4-7-8 itself. In 4-7-8 the breath out is twice the breath in.
How to do each
Box breathing
- Breathe in for 4 seconds.
- Hold the breath for 4 seconds.
- Breathe out for 4 seconds.
- Hold with your lungs empty for 4 seconds.
- Repeat for at least four rounds, about a minute. If the holds feel tight, drop them and breathe in for 4 and out for 4.
More on box breathing: where it comes from, cautions and questions.
4-7-8 breathing
- Breathe in through your nose for 4 seconds.
- Hold your breath for 7 seconds.
- Breathe out through your mouth for 8 seconds, lips slightly pursed, so you can hear it.
- Repeat for four rounds, about 80 seconds. If the hold is uncomfortable, shorten it.
More on 4-7-8 breathing: where it comes from, cautions and questions.
Questions
What’s better, box breathing or 4-7-8?
They suit different moments. Box breathing keeps every count equal and is easy to do anywhere, including just before you speak. 4-7-8 has a longer hold and a breath out twice the breath in, which is more relaxing and can make some people lightheaded, so it fits the end of the day better than the middle of it.
What is the best breathing pattern?
No study has compared breathing patterns closely enough to name one. The best supported finding is about pace: a 2018 review of 15 studies linked breathing under ten breaths a minute with more relaxation and less anxiety. Box breathing and 4-7-8 both run at under four breaths a minute, so either fits. Pick the one you will keep doing.
Who should not do box breathing?
If breath holds make you uncomfortable, or you are prone to panic or to feeling short of air, skip the holds and breathe in for 4 and out for 4. If you have a heart or lung condition, check with a doctor before practising breath holds, and stop if you feel lightheaded.
How many times should I do the 4-7-8 breathing method?
Andrew Weil recommends no more than four rounds at a time while you are learning it, which takes about 80 seconds. In the 2022 study by Vierra and colleagues, people did three sets of six rounds.