Skip to main content

The stages of burnout: what the research supports

We found no study showing burnout moves through 5 or 12 stages in order. Where the lists come from, and the burnout profiles researchers did find.

Written by
Pauso Team
Published
Updated
Reading time
5 minutes

There is no agreed set of burnout stages. The 5-stage and 12-stage lists shared online describe how burnout can feel as it gets worse, but we could not find a peer-reviewed study that tests either one. Researchers measure burnout as three separate scores instead: exhaustion, cynicism about the job, and a sense of doing it less well.

When researchers sort people by those three scores, they find distinct patterns, which they call profiles. Leiter and Maslach's 2016 study found five. Someone with one profile is not necessarily on the way to another.

Where the 12 stages of burnout come from

The psychologist Herbert Freudenberger described the symptoms of burnout in his 1974 paper "Staff burn-out", in the Journal of Social Issues. The 12-stage list comes from a later book by Freudenberger and Gail North, as a 2019 review in Frontiers in Psychiatry sets out. It starts with a compulsion to prove yourself and working harder, moves through neglecting your own needs and withdrawing from people, and ends in inner emptiness, depression and collapse.

Other websites give 3, 5 or 7 stages. None of these lists comes with a questionnaire that places you in a stage, and we found no study testing whether people pass through the stages in order. A list can still help someone recognise a pattern in themselves. It cannot tell you which stage you are in, or whether you will reach the next one.

How researchers measure burnout instead

The World Health Organization's ICD-11 definition describes burn-out as a syndrome resulting from chronic workplace stress that has not been successfully managed, with three dimensions:

  1. Feelings of energy depletion or exhaustion.
  2. Increased mental distance from your job, or feelings of negativism or cynicism about it.
  3. Reduced professional efficacy.

The research questionnaire used most, the Maslach Burnout Inventory, scores each dimension separately. Every model below starts from those three scores, so the research describes combinations of them rather than steps.

The research models closest to stages

ModelBuilt fromWhat it describesWhat the research shows
Phase model, Golembiewski et al., 1983High or low scores on the three Maslach dimensionsEight phases of increasing intensity, numbered I to VIIILater studies found the higher phases go with worse scores on other work measures, including a replication in Ghanaian hospitals. The phases rank severity at one point in time.
Burnout profiles, Leiter and Maslach, Burnout Research, 2016Latent profile analysis of 1,766 Canadian health care employees, repeated with 1,166 moreFive profiles: engaged, ineffective, overextended, disengaged and burnoutIn the first sample, 44% engaged, 31% ineffective, 11% overextended, 7% disengaged and 8% burnout. The disengaged profile looked more like full burnout than the overextended one did.
Veterinarians, Jones-Bitton et al., Veterinary Record, 2023The same method on 1,272 Canadian veterinariansFour profiles10.8% engaged, 18.9% ineffective, 29.6% overextended, 40.7% burnout.
Students, Aguayo-Estremera et al., Healthcare, 20241,162 Spanish nursing and psychology studentsTested the five profilesThe burnout, overextended and engaged profiles replicated. The ineffective and disengaged ones did not cleanly.

The five burnout profiles

RowExhaustionCynicismInefficacy
EngagedLowLowLow
IneffectiveLowLowHigh
OverextendedHighLowLow
DisengagedLowHighLow
BurnoutHighHighHigh
Source: Leiter and Maslach, Burnout Research, 2016

Each of Leiter and Maslach's profiles describes a different problem, which makes them more useful than a numbered list. The shares below are from their first sample of 1,766 health care employees in eastern Canada, and the second sample of 1,166 is in brackets.

  • Engaged. Low on all three dimensions. The person has energy for the work, feels connected to it and is confident in it. 44% of the first sample (47%).
  • Ineffective. Doubts about doing the job well, without exhaustion or cynicism. 31% (20%), the most common problem profile in both samples.
  • Overextended. Exhausted, but still committed and still effective. This is what most people picture when they say burnout. 11% (17%).
  • Disengaged. Cynical and distant from the job, without being exhausted. 7% (12%). In the second sample this profile was high on exhaustion as well, which the authors list as a limitation.
  • Burnout. High on all three. 8% (4%).

A cynical colleague may be worse off than a tired one

In Leiter and Maslach's first sample, people with the disengaged profile rated their working relationships significantly worse than overextended people did, and rated their job satisfaction and resources lower too, though the resources difference was not significant. On each of those measures they sat between the overextended and burnout profiles. Only on workload did overextended people score worse. The authors concluded that this "argues against the use of exhaustion alone as a proxy for burnout". Someone who has stopped caring about the work, but is not tired, may be in a worse place than someone who is tired and still cares.

Does burnout get worse in a fixed order?

Nobody has shown that it does. The profile studies above measured people once, so they show which patterns exist and say nothing about the path between them.

What the longer studies do show is that time matters. In a Swedish study of 232 patients treated for stress-related exhaustion, people who had symptoms for longer before seeking care recovered more slowly, and a third still had clinical burnout scores 18 months later (Glise et al., BMC Psychiatry, 2012). Whatever order the symptoms arrive in, waiting makes recovery longer. How to recover from burnout covers what those follow-ups found.

Which profile is closest to you?

Ask yourself the three questions the dimensions point to:

  1. Am I exhausted most days, in a way a weekend does not fix?
  2. Have I started to care less about the work, or about the people it is for?
  3. Do I feel I am doing the job less well than I used to?

Yes to the first only is closest to overextended. Yes to the second without the first is closest to disengaged, and yes to the third only is closest to ineffective. Yes to all three is the burnout profile. For a score, the burnout test uses the Copenhagen Burnout Inventory, a free, validated questionnaire that scores personal and work-related burnout from 0 to 100 in about two minutes.

What the profiles mean for a manager

The early signs differ from person to person. The overextended person works late and looks tired. The disengaged one goes quiet in meetings, stops volunteering ideas, and may never look tired at all. The signs of team burnout maps those behaviours to the three dimensions.

The causes are usually shared. Gallup's study of nearly 7,500 employees tied burnout most strongly to unfair treatment, an unmanageable workload, unclear communication from managers, lack of manager support and unreasonable time pressure. Fixing those helps every profile on the team.